Myth #3 – Organic Church is a Spontaneous Free-For-All
Many people who leave institutional churches think that “organic church” means that now there will be absolutely no structure, no planning or preparation, and everyone will be free to share anything they want. This could not be further from the truth. These people have never experienced authentic organic church life and yet somehow make these sweeping statements based upon their own reactions to the religious system. This is definitely a reactionary mindset and is based upon nothing else but a “wish dream”, which is their own idea of what the church should look like. So let’s take a quick look at these three ideas to test and see if they can hold any water.
Idea #1 – The Church Needs Absolutely No Structure
This is a common idea among some newbies after leaving the institutional church. The idea (here again) is reactionary and is based upon the false assumption that organic church is simply the opposite of institutional church. That’s just not true. Organic church is in a wholly different category, mindset, and paradigm then the institutional. It’s not just the opposite. It isn’t even in the same universe!
It’s not that we throw away structure in the organic, but rather that structure comes to have a whole new meaning for us. Of course there is still structure in organic church, but this structure is not mechanical as in the system, it is organic. That means it has a totally different nature. The essence of organic structure is based upon the indwelling life of Christ, not any man-made mechanism that is external.
Paul used the revolutionary metaphor of the Body of Christ in his writings. If the authentic church is a body (and it is!) then we need to ask the question; does the body have structure? Does your human body have structure? The obvious answer is yes and that structure is the skeleton. Notice with me that the structure is completely based upon life and that it is hidden. But what would happen if you didn’t have a skeleton? Your body would collapse into a pile of flesh on the floor! And that’s exactly what happens to many groups who want to be “organic” and without any structure. They end up being nothing more than a pile of flesh in the middle of a living room somewhere!
The purpose of the structure of the body is to support the life of the Body. Watchman Nee once said that form follows life, not the other way around. We can never get life out of form or structure. That has become painfully obvious down through the centuries of institutional Christianity. Spiritual life only comes from the Person of Jesus Christ Himself. But once we begin to experience and live by that life together, there will need to be some basic (life-supporting) structure.
Idea #2 – The Church Needs No Planning or Preparation
This assumes the idea that all planning and/or preparation is institutional and therefore the church meetings must all be very spontaneous. Therefore, we should not plan or prepare for our meetings. I have worked with organic groups of believers for over twenty years and I can tell you that this idea can hold no water whatsoever. You just try it and see if your group doesn’t end up being a boring week-after-week, the same people sharing every time, institutional meeting in a living room. I have seen it happen many times. Groups start out with the idea that everyone will just show up, the Holy Spirit will lead, and the meetings will all be very glorious! It sounds very spiritually romantic but it just plain doesn’t work! Why not? Two main reasons.
First of all, sitting in a pew for years does not equip you to function as a member of the Body of Christ! You have only been equipped to sit and listen, not to function. This is why God has called some in His Body to equip the saints to do the work of the ministry (Eph.4:11,12). These outside workers will come and train and equip the group to function as the Body, live by the life of Christ, and live as a community/family. This is how it was done in the New Testament church. Sounds like preparation and planning to me!
I am not saying here that every meeting needs to be planned out in a detailed way. Some meetings should not be planned. But all meetings will require preparation. The bare minimum preparation for meetings is you abiding in Christ every day! A group that doesn’t ever plan for meetings will become very lazy and a few of the people will end up doing all the sharing after a while. A group that plans every meeting will plum wear itself out! Wisdom comes in the balance of planned and unplanned meetings all built upon the preparation of abiding in the Vine on a daily basis.
Idea #3 – The Meeting is an Open Forum for Anyone to Say Anything
Groups that hold to this belief won’t be around very long! The Church of Jesus Christ is not a rap-session or a free-for-all kind of share your ignorance session. We are not coming to blab. We are coming to express the Christ who lives within us! The meetings do not exist for you to share your agenda or your pet doctrine. And the church definitely does not exist as a platform for your so called ministry! She is there to express and display her Lord.
In first Corinthians Paul gives instruction to a church that was abusing just about everything. What we gain is a window that we can peek into to see the healthy life of an authentic eklessia. In chapter fourteen he gives some guidelines for meetings. After reading that chapter it is very clear that the purpose of the gathering of the whole church was to edify (build up) the body. Let me ask you; what is it that edifies the Body? The Head! Only the life of the Head can build up the Body (see Eph. 4:15,16; Ps. 133). So only those things which build up the body should be shared in the meetings of the church. It’s not a free-for-all where anyone can express the thoughts running through their head! It’s the place and time where the body gets to fully express the life of the Head.
It’s very apparent that the early churches were not forums for thoughts, or discussion sessions about doctrine. Paul tells us (again in chapter 14) that there is a “tool” which can be used in the gathering to express Christ and edify the body. What is this tool? He called it prophecy. But what is prophecy? It is the unveiling of Jesus Christ.
“…For the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy.” Rev. 19:10b
It’s all about Him! Not you or your ministry! It’s HIS testimony and HIS revealing and HIS riches being declared.
And Paul told us that WE CAN ALL prophesy one by one so that the Body may be edified. He also told us that when the prophets speak, the others should judge. This doesn’t sound like a free-for-all to me!
“To me, the very least of all saints, this grace was given, to preach to the Gentiles the unfathomable riches of Christ, and to bring to light what is the administration of the mystery which for ages has been hidden in God who created all things; so that the manifold wisdom of God might now be made known through the church to the rulers and the authorities in the heavenly places.” Ephesians 3:8-10
Brothers and sisters, this is a very high and heavenly calling!
Mike Burleson said:
Thanks so much for this post. Needed to be said!
LikeLike
Seth said:
Thank you for clearing the path for His life to be pre-eminent in our midst. May we all be captured by an unparalleled sighting of this glorious Lord.
LikeLike
Josh L said:
Another great article, Milt! Thanks for taking the time to spell all this out for us.
LikeLike
Steve Simms said:
Good thoughts, Milt!
LikeLike
Don said:
Many great expressions here. Thank you. A few that stood out to me are:
idea 1: “the structure is completely based upon life” 1 Corinthians 3:6-9 touches this – on the farm that belongs to God some plant and some water but God gives the growth. The structure is not by our arranging but out of the growth He gives.
idea 2: “sitting in a pew does not equip us to function as a member of the body of Christ” and idea 3: “we are coming to express the Christ who lives in us” If we are practically in the fellowship of Jesus Christ (1 Cor 1:9) then we have something about Christ to speak. As for preparation, Psalm 45:1 says that I speak what I have made (or composed) touching the King.
LikeLike
Jamal Jivanjee said:
Milt,
Thanks so much for writing this. I appreciate you sharing this perspective with us as your experience in organic church life is absolutely vital. I am convinced that a lot of needless heartache could be avoided if we will take seriously the suggestions that you have shared with us. I’m thankful for you brother!
LikeLike
Michael Young said:
Milt,
Thanks for clarifying these ideas that tend to spring out from nowhere. I’m reminded of somewhere in 1 Corinthians where Paul is suggesting that “prophets share one at a time” (paraphrased) and that “the word of a prophet is subject to the prophet” (which in Christ we are ALL prophets and priests!) which I’ve always undestood that if we have something of Christ to share, that “word” is subject to us. Meaning, that we can wait our turn or wait until a more appropiate time to share that revelation. But that’s just one man’s interpretaion :). I know I’ve shared things in meetings that may have been the Lord, but were totally bad timing and it fell to the floor lol. It’s all part of the learning process.
Thanks for sharing Milt!
LikeLike
kaela said:
I love how you capitalize the Body. Hallelujah, we are part of Him.
LikeLike
Quincy Zikmund said:
Thanks for sharing this, Milt. I’ve been out of the institutional expression of the church for about 2.5 years now and have to yet to experience authentic church life consistently. After reading your post I’m convinced that one big reason for this is that the I had this “free for all” mindset when first starting this journey. I really like the example of the human body’s structure. That really puts things into perspective for me. Thank you again.
LikeLike
Pingback: Forgetting to Hold Fast to What is Good | // Divine Discontent
david bolton said:
Thanks, Milt. Well said on all points. I’ve experienced the effects of these misconceptions when they prevail in a group. Not fun. Not life. Not Him. Learning to function as His body under His Headship and by His life does not come easily. We need those who can equip the Body unto this end. Your counsel in this post is excellent and very needed.
LikeLike